Author Archives: Matthew Lug - Page 28

First Anniversary Reader Poll

Tell me what you want, what you oh hell no I’m not doing a Spice Girls reference

In case you missed it, my first Reader Poll revealed that I have a reader!  [Update: It’s up to 4, woo!  And back to one after I replaced the polling system.]  Now, dear reader, you have a chance to shape the content over the next year, in so far as your opinions happen to match up with what I end up doing.  Hey, you get what you pay for and I’m the only one paying for this site.  I love free marketing data though, so please fill out this survey honestly (or at least humorously) and maybe your voice will be heard.  Unless nobody fills this out, in which case I’ll just interpret that as a vote of confidence in whatever I’m doing.  Interpreting data is fun.

General Content

How often do you visit this site?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

What features are you most interested in?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

When do you lose interest in a post?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

What would most improve the content on this site?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Baseball Card Coverage

What baseball card products are you most interested in?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

What types of baseball cards are you most interested in?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Manufactured memorabilia relics are:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

I want to see cards that:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Site Design

The sidebar

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The backgrounds

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

The theme

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Overall, the site design is:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

2012 State of the Site

Now with content!

If you were viewing this site a year ago, well, there wouldn’t have been much here.  More likely, the URL wouldn’t resolve and you wouldn’t have been viewing anything.  I guess it didn’t take much to improve over last year if last year didn’t exist.

With that said, the state of the site is, well, incomplete.  While the various colors and styles of Mets uniforms are more or less covered, things never progressed beyond that.  There’s still 29 other teams (30 if you count the Nationals and Expos separately) plus All-Star, Futures Game, and WBC teams, among others.  And then there’s all of the non-uniform material: jackets, hats, shoes, fielding gloves, batting gloves, catching equipment, etc.

And bats!  Those should be up early in the coming year along with the last of the 2012 product reviews and the thrilling conclusion to Upper Deck: A Love Story.  There’s plenty more content to look forward to, whenever I get around to wrapping some of it up.

In case you’ve lost track of what content has gone up in the last year or so, I put together a Site Index to keep everything organized.  You can get to it from the tabs at the top of each page.  Speaking of the tabs, they’ve been updated to match the 2013 uniforms, sort of.  Black is gone and the road grays and home/road blues have taken over.

As for the rest of the site design, well, not much has changed there.  The sidebar is still a mess and I don’t think the comment boxes are quite right, but the lack of comments has hidden that problem.  The sidebar on the other hand, well, that needs work.  There are also more than a few other sites and blogs that I want to link to, but it’s going to look like a big mess if I can’t figure out how to present everything.

Content in general hasn’t quite gone as planned.  Current products took priority over older products and for some reason game recaps became a big part of this site.  What’s up with that?  I think the game recaps are here to stay (even if they aren’t strictly on topic), but there should be more coverage of older baseball card products as I get more scanning done.  I’m not sure what else we’ll see in the coming year, but I’m bad at predicting this sort of thing anyway.  I guess it’ll be a surprise to all of us!

I never did post a decoder ring for my game-used material codes, did I?  I should probably make that a priority before it gets too confusing.  Rest assured though, the jumble of lettering does make some sort of logical sense.  That should become apparent as more styles of material are added.

You do know that there’s an archive of game-used material in here, right?  Check the Uniforms tab up at the top.  I haven’t exactly been advertising it, so I’m guessing that it gets overlooked a lot.

Elsewhere, there’s been some good progress in establishing a place in the fan community.  The Collect the Mets Twitter account passed 100 followers a while back, though I’m pretty sure most of them don’t visit the site, so I’m not sure what to make of that.  Twitter has given me an avenue to interact with influential people and companies though.  To date, several prominent blogs/bloggers, card companies, and other individuals have taken notice of what I’ve been doing through following on Twitter, retweeting, linking to posts, etc.  It’s nothing all that big, but it’s gotten me into the discussion, which is all I’m really after.  After a wait of about 10 months, I also received membership in the Baseball Bloggers Alliance.  It’s not exactly the BBWAA, but then again it’s not the BBWAA.

So that’s where things are at.  Stuff happened, stuff will happen.  Wow, this is a pretty sorry state of affairs.  Everything has to start somewhere though and we’ll just have to move forward from here.  Thanks for your support over the past year and check back in a week for all of the year-end wrap-up posts I can get out the door by New Year’s!

Still reading?  Why not take the First Anniversary Reader Poll?

Curse of the Pinstripes

Was R.A. Dickey’s departure foretold in cardboard?

One of R.A. Dickey’s final Dickeyfaces as a Met at Citi Field

R.A. Dickey’s career has been quite the roller coaster ride so far, hasn’t it?  A lot of us have been along for the ride for the last three years, but the latest development has us in free fall.  Like half of the Marlins just a few weeks ago, Dickey is headed north to the Blue Jays.  In return, the Mets get a legitimate catching prospect, something the organization has been in dire need of for a while.  Josh Thole has done an admirable job, but the team needs to get better and this is a step toward doing that.  Dickey may no longer be a Met (once the deal becomes official anyway), but he has meant a lot to an organization that hasn’t had much to cheer for lately.  I’m glad to have been able to see him pitch at Citi Field in what turned out to be his last game there as a Met.  No matter what he does in Toronto, he’ll always have a special place with the Mets.

How did it come to this?  Why would the Mets, after doing almost nothing to improve the team in the offseason, trade away their best pitcher, a 20 game winner and Cy Young Award recipient?  Have things really gotten so bad that a New York team has to wring every last penny of value out of its assets just to remain viable?  Starting pitching is one of the team’s strengths, but depth is still a concern.  Will Santana be able to hold down a spot in the rotation for the whole season?  Will Wheeler be ready?  Can Mejia, Hefner, McHugh, or whoever else gets called on to fill in be effective enough?  In a twist of irony, Omar Minaya, the very man who signed Dickey, is also the one most responsible for depleting the farm system to the point that it was necessary to trade him for prospects.  Yet another Minaya victory has been negated by his failures.

But what about the crackpot conspiracy theories?  What completely unrelated event could have somehow prevented Dickey from putting on a Mets uniform in 2013?  He wasn’t on any video game boxes, so what could it be?  Well, you’ve come to the right place, because I’ve got the answer you won’t find anywhere else.  Dickey’s pinstripe game-used memorabilia cards in 2012 ensured that he would not appear in a game as a Met in 2013.

Dickey’s pants from his second one-hitter of 2012 sure seemed lucky when Topps got a hold of them and chopped them up for 2012 Topps Triple Threads.  This was a big deal because it was the only time an active player’s pinstriped Mets uniform made it into cards in 2012 and was the first baseball card appearance of a uniform from the cream-ivory period (2010-present).  For a Mets game-used collector, these cards were a dream come true.  But dig a little deeper and a nightmare unfolds.

The only active player with a Mets pinstripe jersey card in 2011 was Carlos Beltran.  Beltran was traded during the 2011 season before this card was released.  The trade brought back Zack Wheeler, so it is seen as a big win for the Mets.  Still, Beltran signed with the Cardinals after the season and has been doing well while the Mets are in desperate need of some outfield help.  So was Beltran retroactively the curse’s first victim?

No, that honor goes to Johan Santana in the ill-fated 2010 Upper Deck Series 1.  Santana is known to prefer the white home uniforms because he believes that they hide the ball better, so pinstripes are unusual for him.  But wait, Santana is still with the Mets, so how could the curse apply?  As it turns out, Santana missed all of 2011 due to injury.  Is this the fate that would have been in store for Dickey had he not been traded?  We may never know.  What we do know is that, starting in 2010, any active Met with a Mets pinstripe memorabilia card has not appeared in a game as a Met the following year.  Is this curse a bit far-fetched?  Maybe, maybe not.  Only time and baseball cards will tell.

Product Spotlight: 2012 Topps Five Star

With great price comes great risk

If you’ve been worried that baseball card products weren’t expensive enough and have been envious of football card collectors with their super-duper-ultra-mega-premium products, Topps has heard your pleas and brought Five Star to baseball for 2012.  With a starting price of $500 per pack (which dropped to around $400 within a couple weeks of release), you were basically paying for a case of cards and only getting the case hits.  The stakes have never been this high, which means that an unprecedented level of disappointment was soon to follow.

So what does $500 get you these days?  Not a whole lot as it turns out.  Here’s the pack breakdown:

1 Active Player Autograph
1 Retired Player Autograph
1 Autographed Booklet or some other autograph
1 Autographed Relic
1 Relic

And, as a last-minute reveal, packs will also include a base card numbered to 80 or 10!  Yes, after they ditched the base cards in Tier 1, they added them in at the last minute for Five Star.  I have no idea what they’re doing over there, but I guess it’s a bonus.

Sounds good, right?  I mean, as long as you don’t pull a bunch of cards that sell in the $10-20 range, but how likely is that?  Almost certain as it turns out, but there’s still a real chance of pulling at least one card that will sell for $100.  So really, you might be able to get $200 out of a pack, which isn’t that bad.  Unless you paid $500 for it.  Oops.  But the big hits!  8 player autographs!  Booklets!  All autographs are on-card and all relics are game-used (just like everything was in 2001…)!  Imagine yourself selling a card for $1500!  Which probably won’t happen until you’ve gone through at least four packs, or possibly four cases…  But at least you have some nice stuff left over after selling off the hits.  Oh, right, there’s nothing else there, just the seconds of enjoyment from opening packs.  Five Star sells you on the concept and the experience, which may be all you walk away with after putting your money down.

I bailed out of the high-dollar pack market way back in the beginning with SP Game Bat and Pacific Private Stock in 2001.  $20 per pack was pushing it back then and it didn’t take more than a couple of worthless packs to sour me on the whole concept.  Buying singles on the secondary market was always a better deal and that remains true to this day.  I haven’t touched packs of any of this year’s other high-end products and I’m not taking any chances with Five Star.  But there are some nice must-have cards in this product that will cost you a lot less than $500 to pick up.  The cards are all 4mm thick, which is annoying because common toploader sizes go from 3.5mm to 5mm with nothing in between.  And they all have a massive problem with chipping and corner wear.

Base Cards

Base: Numbered to 80
Rainbow: Numbered to 10

Mets: Johan Santana, Tom Seaver, David Wright

Added at the last minute, these are super-thick cards that look a lot like the base autographs.  David Wright is here as always, joined by Tom Seaver and Johan Santana.  If you were hoping for a deep field of Mets, you might as well stop reading now because Dave Kingman and R.A. Dickey are the only other Mets in the entire product (and people are complaining about there being too many lesser players in Five Star…).  As with everything else in Five Star, these are heavily color-coded: red for retired players and blue for active players, with the stone pattern from the cardbacks (rotated 180 degrees) as a border.  There’s a lot of design here and one big player picture, which looks to me like it’s trying too hard to look premium.  I’ve seen nicer designs on early ’90s products and those didn’t sell for $500 per pack.

Jumbo Jersey Relics

Silver: Numbered to 92
Gold: Numbered to 25
Rainbow: Numbered to 1

Mets: Johan Santana, David Wright

Jumbo relics are great in normal products, but they’re largely just junk in this one.  Santana and Wright both have white and gray swatches here, so there’s nothing to get excited about.  They’re cheap at least.  The 1/1s have a piece of patch, but the premium price that they’ll fetch (probably around 1/4 of the price of a pack) isn’t really worth it to buyers or sellers.

Five Star Autographs

Silver: Numbering Varies
Rainbow: Numbered to 25

Mets: Dave Kingman, Tom Seaver, David Wright

While these cards look a lot like the base cards, the designs are completely different, though mostly the same.  The border switches from the light stone in the base cards to a very dark wood grain here, which makes the chipping more visible.

Five Star Quotable Autographs

Numbered to 10

Mets: Tom Seaver, David Wright

How can you not like a David Wright autograph with a “Let’s Go Mets!” inscription?  These are way out of my price range unfortunately, but the hobby could use more of this kind of variety in autograph cards.

Five Star Silver Ink Autographs

Silver Ink: Numbered to 99
Gold Ink Gold Border: Numbered to 10 or less
Gold Ink Purple Border: Numbered to 10 or less
Gold Ink Red Border: Numbered to 10 or less

Mets: R.A. Dickey, Dave Kingman, David Wright

Notable here are the first on-card autographs from R.A. Dickey.  The gold ink parallels are the big hits (well, bigger, it’s hard to call a $50-100 card a “big hit” in a $500 pack), but even the silver ink base versions look great.  These are the real must-have autographs in Five Star, skip the rest if you’re just looking for one or two nice cards.  Shame about the chipping.

Five Star Booklet Triple Relic Autograph

Silver: #d/99 or less (49 for Wright)
Gold: Numbered to 10
Rainbow: Numbered to 1

Mets: David Wright

Oh boy, three small white pieces of fabric (some dirty) and an autograph on the other piece of the booklet when there’s still plenty of room on the relic side.  These just don’t interest me at all.

Multiplayer Cards

Numbered to 5

Mets: Johan Santana (2 and 4 Patch), David Wright (2, 3, 4, and 8 Patch)

The cards that got people drooling over 5 Star were the massive multiplayer cards with patches or autographs from up to 8 different players.  Numbered to only 5 each (10 for some of the autograph cards), the odds of pulling one are slim, but at least you stand a chance at getting your money back if you do.  David Wright and Johan Santana are the only Mets here, with both of the Santanas on cards that also feature Wright, for a total of four different cards.

Other Cool Stuff

Sorry, no Mets here.  5 Star has some nice extremely limited cards, but the Mets didn’t make the cut.

Bottom Line

Anything numbered to more than 10 in this product is junk.  That’s great for singles buyers, not so great for pack breakers.  Of the Mets cards numbered to more than 10, only the Wright, Dickey, and Seaver autographs and the Wright triple relic autograph will sell for more than $30, with most others regularly selling for less than $20.  That means you should be able to get all of the Mets cards numbered to more than 10 plus the base cards numbered to 10 for around $500, if you can find enough sellers willing to take a chance on the product and then sell the contents for fair market value.  That’s 20 cards, 10 of them autographed, for the price of one pack.  You’re guaranteed not to get any big hits this way, but at least you know what you’ll be getting.  That is, a bunch of really thick cards with fancy designs and widespread chipping.  Eh, maybe this isn’t a product to buy into that big.

Game Recap: 27 September 2012, Pirates at Mets

Everything’s coming up Dickey

Yeah, this is a month two months late, but do you have any more pressing Mets news to read in late October November?

September 27 at Citi Field was a day of contradictions.  The Mets were nearing the end of another losing season, but fans showed up in droves to cheer on a winner.  No, not Keith Hernandez’s mustache, it was R.A. Dickey who put butts in seats after the previous games in the series failed to draw a crowd.  In search of his 20th win, Dickey rescheduled his start to land on the final game at Citi Field in 2012.  But before we get to that, something about this sounds familiar.  A Mets star going for a milestone in New York against the Pirates?  I’ve seen that one before in the only other home Mets game I ever attended, though the outcome was not a pleasant one.

The year was 1988 and the Mets were headed to their second division championship in three years.  On a summer evening, I was headed to Shea Stadium with my brother’s Boy Scout troop to see my first home Mets game and what would be my only game at Shea Stadium.  One of the conditions of my attendance was wearing some form of troop clothing, which in this case was a green hat.  I was not thrilled with this arrangement, but I had no choice but to comply.

As the LaGuardia air traffic thundered overhead, seemingly only just beyond arm’s reach from the upper deck, Gary Carter was trying for his 300th home run.  A Roger Rabbit themed fan sign implored Carter to hit #300 (I told you this was 1988…).  He did not.  Things quickly fell apart and the Pirates had a lead that was too much to hope for the Mets to come back from.  We were forced to leave in the 8th inning so we could beat the traffic.  We did not.

Citi Field has been a place that I’ve wanted to visit since it opened in 2010, but it’s just too far away for a casual visit and I’m not all that familiar with New York City despite living in its local television viewing area for my entire childhood.  Going to a game would be nice, but there was no reason to make it a priority, especially with the last few dismal seasons of Mets baseball.  I kept hearing about things to see there, but I didn’t know if I would ever get to see them.  The Jackie Robinson Rotunda.  The Mets Hall of Fame and Museum.  The old Shea Stadium Home Run Apple.  The team store and all of the Mets merchandise that isn’t available on the team’s web site.  Shake Shack.  Would I ever get to experience any of this?

As the 2012 season drew closer to its end (and another Mets 4th place finish), it looked like another year would go by without a Citi Field visit.  When I saw that a certain polarizing t-shirt magnate was organizing a group trip to the final home game, I was intrigued, but I wasn’t sure I could make a trip like that happen.  Sure, I haven’t been back to visit my parents in a while and I could just take the train down from there, but there was always a chance of something coming up at the last minute to derail any plans.  With nothing firmly scheduled, tickets for the game were running out.  I could always just get a seat somewhere else, but then I could have done that at any point this year.  If I didn’t get in on the group purchase, it would undermine my procrastination and throw my world into chaos.  So I bought a ticket and hoped for the best.

The world didn’t end and nothing conspired against me to make my plan go awry.  With 24 hours before game time, I was just a four hour drive and a two hour train ride away from Citi Field.

And there it was.  Stepping down from the subway platform revealed the stadium in all its glory.  The old home run apple was front and center with a barber’s chair (and pole) up on a stage in preparation for Keith Hernandez’s mustache shaving.  As exciting as that sounded, it seemed to be well-covered enough to skip and catch up on later.  I took my first opportunity to enter the stadium and, a bag check and a pat down later (they have some real hands on staff in this place), I was in the famed Jackie Robinson Rotunda.  After taking in the underwhelming sight and hitting the team store, it was off to the field in search of autographs.

Unfortunately, there was no formal batting practice that day and only a few pitchers who would not be in the game were warming up.  Josh Edgin and Collin McHugh worked their way down the crowd that had gathered at the front of the field level seats.  While these were two of the players I was most interested in getting autographs from (neither has any certified autograph cards), it was a little disappointing to see only two players out signing.  From there it was back to the team store and a few of the other shops and then my seat.  And then Shake Shack to see what all the fuss was about.

Now, remember that bit about being assigned group outing clothing?  Man, that sucked.  Oh, right, this ticket came with a t-shirt…  At least it’s blue.  When the shirts were made, the starting pitcher wasn’t known, but it would almost certainly not be R.A. Dickey.  Until he rearranged his schedule to give the New York fans a chance to see his 20th win.  With Dickey pitching, I couldn’t pass up a chance to wear my Dickey 2012 All-Star jersey, so the t-shirt would have to settle for being an undershirt.  Surprisingly, almost everyone in the section was wearing the shirt (and at least two also had the Dickey jersey).  There was that one guy in a Pirates jersey, but that’s all I’ll say about that desperate cry for attention.  With several empty seats on either side of me, I settled in for what was sure to be an exciting game, especially once the beer vendor got to this section…

With defense like this, you’re gonna need a lot of strikeouts…

Dickey emerged from the bullpen to a standing ovation, his first of many at this game.  He was dealing strikeouts from the start, with fans cheering every strike.  This was actually quite helpful with the main scoreboards behind me and the information displayed on the secondary boards along the upper level difficult to decipher at a glance – cheer for strike, silence for ball.  It was very much a playoff game atmosphere, even if there were only about 30,000 fans in the park.  Unfortunately, a no-hitter was quickly off the table with a leadoff double in the second, as was a shutout after the inning’s second double.  With three strikeouts and four hits in the second inning alone, the Pirates were making solid contact when they weren’t striking out and the balls kept finding their way past the Mets’ defenders.  Things were not looking good.

The Mets were going to need some runs if they were going to get Dickey his 20th win.  Ike got things started with a home run in the bottom of the second and Mike Baxter almost added a second in the inning with a ball that was clearly headed over the wall.  Until Travis Snyder made an Endy-style leaping catch to grab it.  Watching it happen from behind the wall and seeing a glove appear out of nowhere is an interesting experience, but nobody there was all that thrilled to see a spectacular play that took a home run away from the home team.

The Pirates added a run in the 4th on a home run by former Met Rod Barajas, but I wasn’t paying attention because everyone in the section was busy checking in with Kevin.  The Mets answered back with a run on three hits in the bottom of the inning and Dickey breezed through the Pirates in the top of the 5th with three Ks and a walk to get the Mets back up to bat.  After Andres Torres walked to start off the bottom of the 5th, Ruben Tejada and Daniel Murphy singled to tie the game at three apiece.  David Wright, not to be shown up by Murphy, cleared the bases with a three-run home run.  Ex-Met Hisanori Takahashi finished off the inning, leaving the Mets with just a three-run lead.  That would usually be plenty for Dickey, but the trouble in the 2nd combined with all of the pitches that come with a lot of strikeouts were wearing him down.  The prospect of the bullpen taking over tempered the excitement of watching Dickey settle in and pitch like an ace.

After six innings, Dickey was nearing the end of his day.  He was in line for the win if the bullpen could hold on, but he looked like he still had one inning left in him after a 1-2-3 6th.  As interesting as things were in the outfield seats, the action was just too far away for clear shots.  And so I left to find a better angle for the remainder of the game.  The first base side of the concourse was far too crowded to get a view of the field, so I continued around to the third base side where I found one small gap to work with.  Dickey made it through the 7th without incident, but his pitch count was high enough to guarantee that he wouldn’t be back for the 8th.  And then he walked up to the plate to lead off in bottom of the inning.

All bets were off now that it was clear that Dickey would come out for the 8th, pitch count be damned.  Not only that, but he clearly had plans with the bat, swinging for a hit in his final at bat of the day.  He was then forced out at second on a fielder’s choice and walked off to another ovation.  The Mets failed to pad their lead in the inning, only getting a runner past first when Daniel Murphy stole second before David Wright grounded out to end the inning.

DICKKKKKKKKKKKKKEY!

The 8th inning would have to be his last, right?  Dickey started the inning off with a pair of strikeouts and the stadium got louder and louder with every strike.  The crowd was roaring when he got to two strikes on Travis Snyder, but ball 4 put an end to that.  Once again, Snyder had silenced the crowd.  Dickey then handed over the ball and returned to the dugout to another ovation, tipping his cap to the crowd as Josh Thole traded in his glove for something that less resembled a gaping maw of doom.

Jon Rauch came in to face Rod Barajas and quickly gave up a fly ball to deep left field.  The ball was barely off the bat before someone in front of me shouted “You Suck!”  That ball was caught, but the scene repeated itself in the 9th with a different result.  Rauch had a good season, but he tended to give up the kind of big hits that people remember.  Alex Presley got this day’s big hit off of Rauch with one out in the 9th, a two-run home run that ended Rauch’s day and came close to ending Dickey’s chances at a win.  With the lead cut to one run, Bobby Parnell was brought in to get the final two outs.  A fly ball to right looked like it could drop, but Mike Baxter got there in time to make the final out.  He didn’t even have to crash into a wall for this one.

Who but Mike Baxter?

After more than 20 years, the Mets had a 20-game winner.  Dickey once more took the field for high fives and Baxter handed him the ball that clinched it.  The crowd cheered and nobody was quick to leave as Dickey stayed behind for an on-field interview.  When it was time to leave, a good chunk of the crowd headed for the team store.  I spent some time in the adjoining museum (which had no line to get in) and then began the long trip back.  R.A. Dickey had just added a 13-K exclamation point to his Cy Young case, but the world would have to wait until November 14 for the results.  On that day, a knuckleballer was awarded the Cy Young award for the first time in baseball history.

Mets Game-Used History: The Fall of Upper Deck

Milestones and the end of the road

Remember when I started this blog with the first entry in this series?  Probably not, that was almost a year ago…  I’m going out of sequence with the second part because the second part chronologically (1998-1999) is pretty boring.  Instead, I’m going straight to 2010 with a card from an insert set that started in 1999 featuring a player whose first game-used cards appeared in 1998.  So yeah, we’re still kinda in 1998-1999 for this piece.

Gary Sheffield has been a personal favorite of mine (as much as I was ever able to have favorites before R.A. Dickey came along) for a long time now, dating back to the day I pulled his error rookie card out of a pack of 1989 Upper Deck.  It is fitting then that Sheffield is also the player that I associate with 2010 Upper Deck Series 1, the final major baseball card product from what was once the most innovative sports card manufacturer on the planet.  I was thrilled when Sheff was picked up by the Mets in 2009 after being released by the Tigers, not because he was a superstar player (his best days were long behind him), but because of the wealth of game-used cards he had amassed over his career.  Between countless teams and several All-Star games, Sheffield had been one of the most prolific game-used subjects over the previous decade.  It didn’t hurt that he was Dwight Gooden’s nephew either.

Oh, right, he was also on the verge of hitting his 500th home run.  No Met had ever hit a 500th home run, so that would be a first.  The baseball card connection here is Upper Deck’s A Piece of History 500 Club game-used bat insert set, the longest-running game-used insert set in history.  Started in 1999 with cards spread out over several products over the next few years until the present club was complete, with new cards showing up as new players hit the 500 home run milestone, the 500 Club bat card set would finish in 2010 with Sheffield as the final member to be recognized.  As you can see, he appeared in a Mets uniform, the only member of the club so attired.  And that’s kind of the problem.

You see, MLB Properties has a soft spot for monopolies and thought it would be swell to have just one officially licensed baseball card manufacturer starting in 2010.  With two manufacturers still licensed by the MLB Players Association in 2009, the finalists were the old standard Topps and the brash 20 year old upstart Upper Deck.  MLB Properties went with Topps and forced Upper Deck into the unlicensed card market formerly occupied by Donruss.  The loss of the MLB license meant that Upper Deck would no longer be able to use MLB team logos and names.  Most companies in this position take extreme measures to airbrush/photoshop out anything and everything that could be considered a logo or property of MLB Properties.  As you can see above, Upper Deck went with angles and cropping that obscures the logos but doesn’t hide them completely.  While that’s pushing the limits of legality, they should still be safe, right?  Well, only if MLB doesn’t look on the back of the card.

And right there are the Mets sleeve and helmet logos in plain view, with no attempt made to get rid of them.  To its credit, UD did include the statement “NOT authorized by Major League Baseball or its Member Teams,” but I don’t think a capital NOT is going to pass legal muster.  For a second opinion, let’s consult with Johan Santana.

It’s almost like they were trying to put as much of the logos on the card as possible without being overt about it.  Between the two cards, we’ve also got the complete Citi Field Inaugural Season sleeve and hat logos in full view, which probably isn’t helping matters any.  That’s just asking to get your pants sued off, which is precisely what MLB Properties did.  As is the norm these days, they agreed on a settlement in lieu of an actual trial.  The terms included some cash (which UD was late paying) and an agreement that Upper Deck would not use any MLB Properties logos in the future (which they shouldn’t have been doing anyway) and would not use photographs that had been altered to remove or obscure any MLB Properties logos (which they clearly had no interest or ability in doing in the first place).  In exchange, Upper Deck wouldn’t have to recall any infringing products that had already been shipped.  Everybody wins!

This all but spelled the end of Upper Deck as a baseball card manufacturer.  Losing the MLB Properties license was a big blow, but other companies like Playoff/Donruss, Panini/Donruss, and Razor/Leaf have gone on without licenses.  In the event that MLB Properties reconsiders granting an exclusive license, there would be a chance of being reinstated.  Well, except for the whole snubbing their nose at MLB Properties and the law and napalming that bridge.  There’s no coming back from that kind of mess.

But at least we have this snazzy un-photoshopped Gary Sheffield bat card.